Cookies are one of the most delicious treats in the world, but also one of the most dangerous. Some have self-control and can pick up and eat one cookie and stop, while others want a box or a bowl and to eat until they are stuffed. There are many different kinds to choose from, and most of them are good. The Magic Valley has many great places that offer amazing cookies, and sadly in 2025, Twin Falls will say goodbye to some of their favorite cookies.

Cookies Going Away in the Magic Valley

Credit: pamela_d_mcadams
Credit: pamela_d_mcadams
loading...

Before you freak out, no, none of the delicious places in Twin Falls that offer cookies is closing. Crumbl, Cookie Co, Soda Mix, and other places that offer cookies will remain open. With that said, it is Girl Scout cookie season though, which many residents in the Magic Valley look forward to. While it is nice to donate to a good cause, it is the cookies that have people excited. It is a short season that offers the opportunity to buy incredible cookies, and everyone seems to have their favorite. For many, the S'more cookie is the best, and another popular option is the Toast-Yay! If these are two of your favorite cookies you will be disappointed to find out this is the final season for you to get them in Twin Falls. 

S'mores and Toast-Yay! Cookies Being Discontinued in Idaho

Credit: Deeliver on Unsplash
Credit: Deeliver on Unsplash
loading...

The popular S'mores cookie will be discontinued at the end of this Girl Scout cookie season in the Magic Valley, along with the Toast-Yay! If you are someone that enjoys these cookies you will want to stock up before they are all gone. Make sure to save up or take out a loan, because boxes this year will be $6. You can freeze them and keep them for down the line, after they are gone, or enjoy them all as soon as they get home. If you miss your chance to get any this season, odds are high they will be sold online, but likely for a much higher price due to supply and demand. It is sad to see these delicious options go away, but hopefully, they will be replaced with something just as good or better. If you can't find a Girl Scout to get cookies this season, you can find some at this link

95.7 KEZJ logo
Get our free mobile app

Don't wait to get out and start enjoying Girl Scout cookies now. Make sure to load up on your favorites cause they often go fast and you never know when the one you want will be gone. Stock up on S'mores and Toast-Yay! and enjoy them before they leave the Magic Valley for good. For more details on the cookies being discontinued, you can click the link in the second paragraph above.

Sweet Treat Places Around Twin Falls

Magic Valley Photogenic Foods

Gallery Credit: Restaurants

More From 95.7 KEZJ